Informed Participation
The company establishes ongoing, two-way communication with affected rights holders that provides relevant critical information well in advance of key decision points.
Informed participation through two-way communication enables companies to proactively identify risks, clarify misunderstandings with rights holders, and adapt strategies to the local context. By providing information early and regularly, rights holders – including workers and their representatives – can raise and resolve concerns in a timely and cost-effective manner. Moreover, companies need to have good relations with affected stakeholders such that they know who to contact when problems arise, and a stakeholder-informed process to handle sensitive information.
When company representatives arrived at a consultation at their Brazil operations with a 200-page technical report, community members described feeling overwhelmed as well as excluded. While they wanted the technical and legal information, the company didn’t provide it in a way that they could make sense of.
The company works with rights holders to establish an ongoing two-way communication process that includes:
- Informed participation of affected stakeholders for collaborative analysis and decision-making. Companies should consult with affected stakeholders to determine the information they need as well as the format, delivery method, and timeline so that it is clear and accessible (IFC 2007, 28-30). Moreover, they should share information well in advance of decision-making, and provide information objectively in a way that doesn’t try to sway affected stakeholders’ opinions (TNFD 2023, 37; IFC 2007, 28).31 Keep in mind that some communities don’t use the written language, so alternative accommodations may be necessary.
- Informal meetings and, where available, digital communication tools alongside formal consultation. Creating open, informal spaces for dialogue—such as regular open houses, roundtables, or community forums—encourages more authentic engagement and provides stakeholders with accessible opportunities to express concerns and share perspectives.32 Similarly, meetings in public spaces, where people congregate organically, such as restaurants and local businesses, can promote participation (OECD 2017, 52). Electronic media, such as text messaging and anonymous mobile surveys, can be an effective way to reach affected stakeholders who may be unable or unwilling to participate in in-person meetings, especially in contexts where fear of retaliation or logistical barriers limit open dialogue (IPIECA).
- A process to handle sensitive information (OECD 2017, 53; IFC 2007, 31). When it comes to handling sensitive information, companies should carefully balance transparency with legitimate privacy and confidentiality concerns, including rights holder safety and potential business risks. When these considerations make full disclosure untenable, it is essential for companies to provide clear explanations for why that is the case (OECD 2017, 53). In a few cases, such as discussions around community resettlement, timing the release of information to coincide with face-to-face consultations can be an effective strategy. This approach enables companies to address concerns in real time and facilitates more constructive, meaningful dialogue (IFC 2007, 31).
31Cathal Doyle and Jill Cariño, “Making Free Prior & Informed Consent a Reality: Indigenous Peoples and the Extractive Sector” (Indigenous Peoples Links (PIPLinks), Middlesex University School of Law, The Ecumenical Council for Corporate Responsibility, May 2013), https://www.ecojesuit.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Making-FPIC-a-Reality-Report.pdf.
32Shift, “Using Relationship Data to Improve Business Practices: Measuring Company-Community Relationships at a South African Mine,” March 2021, 10, https://shiftproject.org/resource/case-study-goldfields/.
- A process for engaging in good faith negotiations with workers and their representatives. Good-faith negotiations begin with transparent and reliable information sharing. During negotiations, the credibility of information is key to a productive conversation and resolving conflicting points of view. As such, it’s imperative that all actors involved in the negotiation agree on who is responsible for collecting and reporting data so that all parties trust it. Then the information must be presented in a format and language that foster mutual understanding of the issues and complexities at hand.33
33“Industrial Relations Toolkit,” ITCILO, accessed May 25, 2025, https://www.itcilo.org/courses/industrial-relations-toolkit.
In CAHRAs, two-way communication strategies should be informed by ongoing conflict analysis and tailored to local conditions, including considering the following:
- Setting: Engagement should take place in neutral, non-militarized locations.
- Frequency: Establish a regular cadence for dialogue, while remaining flexible to shifts in the security and political environment.
- Security: Rights holders involved in consultations face elevated risks. Sharing views or vulnerabilities may expose them to retaliation if information is mishandled. Engagements should therefore prioritize safety by using secure, off-site venues, anonymizing feedback, minimizing record keeping when appropriate, and ensuring data is stored securely—ideally outside the conflict zone.
Stakeholder perspectives in CAHRAs can shift rapidly. Lessons learned from conflict-affected and fragile settings indicate that such environments warrant a highly localized approach, joint feedback mechanisms, capacity building for frontline staff, and a reciprocal (versus extractive) approach.
Additionally, companies must be prepared to share with rights holders as much information related to remaining or exiting a conflict zone as they can. Rights holders need access to timely and clear information to assess potential risks, understand the company’s reasoning, and prepare for possible consequences of the company’s presence or withdrawal.